December 21, 2005

You are on the invidual archive page of Assorted WTO briefs. Click Simon World weblog for the main page.
Assorted WTO briefs

While the delegates have flown home, the impact of the WTO meeting on Hong Kong is far exceeding the impact Hong Kong had on the WTO.

1. The government is to promote spending in Wan Chai and Causeway Bay to help shopkeepers make up for the losses they copped for being closed for a week.
2. Peter Gordon suggests the government establish a free trade think tank here in Hong Kong, helping advance our claim to being "Asia's World City".
3. 11 Korean protesters were denied bail but their detainment conditions were improved, while the potential for more serious charges to come later this week was also raised. As a sideline there's the potentially interesting case of a mainlander also arrested but claiming mistaken identity. The Korean government minister visiting Hong Kong has now apologised twice to the city, but also said the protesters will not face any action on their return to Korea. If the law operates properly these protesters will be prosecuted and if found guilty thrown into jail. Demonstrating Hong Kong's adherence to rule of law would tell protesters that they are not above the law. They abused Hong Kong's hospitalilty and whatever their grievances with the WTO, their rioting and destruction was not justified. Think I'm being biased? Try this from Doug Crets in The Standard:

After apologizing publicly for the violent clashes for a second time, Lee said the actions of the protesters were not directed at the Hong Kong government and consequently they did not deserve further punishment by the Korean government on their return.

"I [have] asked the authorities to give some special favor to look into this matter. The demonstration had nothing to do with the sovereignty of the Hong Kong government," Lee said.

In short, the South Korean government is asking for the Hong Kong government to exempt their protesters from the typical workings of the law. But wait, there's more:

A small public relations storm erupted over the weekend as some nongovernment organizations and sympathizers with the Koreans' cause alleged that police overreacted to the protest Saturday. But eyewitness accounts by reporters from The Standard support claims that police action was commensurate with the level of violence.

For more than four hours police warned the Koreans to assemble peacefully and that violent action would be met "with force." Tear gas was only used when the mob became unruly.

Doug also has more on the Curbside blog about his first hand impressions of the riots and Hong Kong's police. He concludes:
But these police didn't do that. They stuck to rigid positions. They followed protocols. They reacted to an action, they didn't, as far as I could tell, create an action. In fact, the very actuality that the Koreans were able to break through Central Plaza to get that far to the convention center tells me that the Koreans kept pushing till they broke the riot police's ideological stance. After that happened, it was all reaction, and then a clamping down.

As I have said before, these demonstrations were about power and control.

What I want to know is, can anyone tell me how I can arrange to spray paint the United States Consulate General and get away with it? Seriously, how does that happen?


4. The most interesting thing to come out of the WTO meeting was the local collaborative effort Curbside @ WTO. A joint venture between the University of Hong Kong's New Media course, blogger ESWN and The Standard newspaper was an outstanding success. Executive editor Susan Rossi, from The Standard, tells us of a virtual triumph for new media. For those interested in the intersection between blogging and mainstream media, this is a must read. Unlike their competition, who were begging for "citizen journalists", The Standard actually put it together and it worked well. For such ad-hoc, fast moving events, this kind of real time news has given us a glimpse of the future of media. It was a true combination of citizen and professional journalism. Best of all, The Standard actually gets it. Here's hoping this experiment was the first of many. ESWN also sums up his impressions of the Curbside experiment, optimistically concluding:
The core team for Curbside will be dispersed after they complete their coursework. Each one of them will probably have their own weblogs and/or fotoblogs. However, there was a moment in time when they all got together to work on a group project that was much bigger than the sum of each one of them.
Don't doubt the importance of this new emerging medium...and I'm talking to you, Richard Li.
5. What did China learn from the Hong Kong anti-riot police?
6. An optimistic Jagdish Bhagwati on the WTO meeting outcome.
7. Who really benefits from fair trade?

posted by Simon on 12.21.05 at 09:42 AM in the WTO category.




Trackbacks:

TrackBack URL for this entry:
http://blog.mu.nu/cgi/trackback.cgi/139957


Send a manual trackback ping to this post.


Comments:

Thank you, Simon. Time for stormy weather, soon.

posted by: doug on 12.21.05 at 11:44 PM [permalink]




Post a Comment:

Name:


Email Address:


URL:


Comments:


Remember your info?










Disclaimer