April 12, 2005

You are on the invidual archive page of The Middle Kingdom middleman. Click Simon World weblog for the main page.
The Middle Kingdom middleman

The world, we are told, is skating on incredibly thin ice. Why?

US February Trade Deficit probably widened to $59 billion. Naturally the culprit is China:

The U.S. trade deficit probably widened in February to $59 billion, the second-largest on record, because of rising imports from China and other countries, economists said before a government report today.
The beauty of trade is one country's deficit is another's surplus. So naturally China must have recorded a massive trade surplus, right? Wrong. China's trade surplus widens as exports surge:
The surplus reached $5.7 billion, up from $4.4 billion in February and rebounding from a $630 million deficit in March 2004.
Hang on a second. China only had a $5.7 billion surplus for the month while the US had a deficit ten times that number? What's going on?

The answer is simple. China is becoming the world's middleman. It imports resources and raw materials from commodity producer countries, it uses its cheap labour to transform those resources into products, and then it exports the finished products to Wal-Mart. China then recycles the "profits" of this process largely by buying US dollars and Government securities. Effectively, the USA is in a giant hire purchase arrangement with China (and others). It might all end in tears. But if the US continues to consume more than it produces and its consumers are rational (in the economic sense) then those consumers are estimating they will be able to repay their accumulated debts down the track. That's their choice. As long as China is prepared to continue funding their largesse the cycle continues.

Imposing tariffs or trade restrictions on China will obviously hurt China itself. But it will also hurt all of those countries that export and run large trade surpluses with China. It will hurt all of those US consumers who are enjoying cheaper clothes, video players and whatever else thanks to China's ability to transform resources into goods reliably and cheaply. America should be thanking China and celebrating the rapid benefits the cycle is bringing both to themselves and the millions of Chinese rising out of poverty.

Next time you hear about the China trade bogey-man, remember this: China isn't the problem, it's the middleman.

posted by Simon on 04.12.05 at 05:30 PM in the




Trackbacks:

TrackBack URL for this entry:
http://blog.mu.nu/cgi/trackback.cgi/74885


Send a manual trackback ping to this post.


Comments:

Fascinating. I may not have followed all the implications, but I enjoyed the explanation. Good stuff, Simon. Thanks.

posted by: RP on 04.12.05 at 09:22 PM [permalink]

But isn't part of Chinese policy to continue funding the US deficit, thereby keeping the yuan low and its products competitive?

posted by: Fabian on 04.12.05 at 09:41 PM [permalink]

The whole "yuan low" thing isn't as much a decision by china to take advantage of its competitors (though that is a huge side effect), it's more a decision by China not to do too many reforms to its extremely undeveloped banking system.
The whole low-RMB situation is actually dangerous for China since the economy is likely to slip when it gets evaluated.

posted by: Andrew on 04.13.05 at 01:44 AM [permalink]

Fabian: that's not part of China's policy. It's a function of having a fixed exchange rate. There's plenty of argument whether China's exchange rate is "too low". The trade surplus seems to indicate it might not be, given it's only slightly in surplus.

posted by: Simon on 04.13.05 at 01:18 PM [permalink]




Post a Comment:

Name:


Email Address:


URL:


Comments:


Remember your info?










Disclaimer